00 / 05
The usual lighting
Globe streetlight, 12,000 lm, 4,000 K white light, 22% of the output going skywards and on at 100% all night.
- Stars
- 315
- Bortle
- 818.43 mag
- Consumption
- 3,116kWh/year
start- Rules
- No
Why it fails
- FHS of 22%: Castile and León Law 15/2010 allows no more than 3% (art. 13.1.a), stricter than the 15% of ITC-EA-03 in zone E3.
- East pavement (P4): 11.4 lx average, more than 20% above the reference 5 lx (max. 6 lx, ITC-EA-02).
01 / 05
No light upwards
Against skyglowShielded road luminaire: 0% upward light. All the light that went to the sky comes down to the street… and is now too much.
- Stars
- 602
- Bortle
- 6-719.15 mag
- Consumption
- 3,116kWh/year
= 00- Rules
- No
Shielding without lowering the output isn't enough: the light that went to the sky now falls on the street and over-lights it.
Why it fails
- High street (M5): 22.6 lx average, more than 20% above the reference 7.5 lx (max. 9 lx, ITC-EA-02).
- High street (M5): uniformity 0.28, below 0.35 (ITC-EA-02).
- East pavement (P4): 23.6 lx average, more than 20% above the reference 5 lx (max. 6 lx, ITC-EA-02).
- West pavement (P4): 9.1 lx average, more than 20% above the reference 5 lx (max. 6 lx, ITC-EA-02).
02 / 05
Only the light the rules require
Against over-lighting2,500 lm per point, staggered every 16 m at a height of 6 m. The carriageway and both pavements reach their class without overshooting.
- Stars
- 1,599
- Bortle
- 520.35 mag
- Consumption
- 938kWh/year
−70% vs 00- Rules
- Compliant
Less light, less safety? Switching off, dimming or reducing streetlights in England and Wales was not associated with more night-time collisions or more crime.9 What helps you see is even light that doesn't dazzle.
What it meets
- FHS 0% (max. 3% in Castile and León, Law 15/2010, art. 13).
- High street (M5): 8.8 lx, reference 7.5 lx (ITC-EA-02).
- East pavement (P4): 5.6 lx, reference 5 lx (ITC-EA-02).
- West pavement (P4): 5.1 lx, reference 5 lx (ITC-EA-02).
03 / 05
Warm light
Against the LED's blueFrom 4,000 K to 2,200 K, amber. Blue light is the most scattered in the atmosphere and the one that dirties the sky most.
- Stars
- 2,950
- Bortle
- 421.24 mag
- Consumption
- 1,158kWh/year
−63% vs 00- Rules
- Compliant
The LED twist, in reverse: the sky gains 1,351 stars. It's the only decision that raises the bill: the model assumes 122 lm/W at 2,200 K versus 150 lm/W at 4,000 K, so the same lumens cost more watts.
What it meets
- FHS 0% (max. 3% in Castile and León, Law 15/2010, art. 13).
- High street (M5): 8.8 lx, reference 7.5 lx (ITC-EA-02).
- East pavement (P4): 5.6 lx, reference 5 lx (ITC-EA-02).
- West pavement (P4): 5.1 lx, reference 5 lx (ITC-EA-02).
04 / 05
Dimming after midnight
Against light nobody usesTime-based dimming: 100% until midnight and 50% for the rest of the night.
- Stars
- 3,565
- Bortle
- 321.56 mag
- Consumption
- 833kWh/year
−73% vs 00- Rules
- Compliant
What it meets
- FHS 0% (max. 3% in Castile and León, Law 15/2010, art. 13).
- High street (M5): 8.8 lx, reference 7.5 lx (ITC-EA-02).
- East pavement (P4): 5.6 lx, reference 5 lx (ITC-EA-02).
- West pavement (P4): 5.1 lx, reference 5 lx (ITC-EA-02).
05 / 05
Presence detection
Against light nobody usesOn top of that: in the small hours the lamp stays on standby (20% of the dimmed level) and goes up to 100% for 90 s when someone passes. Computed with 4 passers-by per hour.
- Stars
- 4,309
- Bortle
- 321.89 mag
- Consumption
- 230kWh/year
−93% vs 00- Rules
- Compliant
Same street, rules met, 13.5 times less energy and 3,994 more stars than at the start.
What it meets
- FHS 0% (max. 3% in Castile and León, Law 15/2010, art. 13).
- High street (M5): 8.8 lx, reference 7.5 lx (ITC-EA-02).
- East pavement (P4): 5.6 lx, reference 5 lx (ITC-EA-02).
- West pavement (P4): 5.1 lx, reference 5 lx (ITC-EA-02).